6mm-284 vs 243

Discuss all aspects of Ammunition and Reloading here.
Post Reply
louie the fly
.17 HMR
Posts: 210
Joined: Sun Aug 24, 2008 11:49 pm
Favourite Cartridge: 25-06
Location: WA

6mm-284 vs 243

Post by louie the fly »

hey lads,

As you may no know from previous posts, im in the market for either a 25-06 or 243 used for everything up to goat sized game. it will most likely be a semi/custom job. I have been giving 243 serious thought and came across the 6mm-284. I found the ballistics to quite impressive (about 150-200fps quicker than 243) but it burns more powder, and cases are more difficult to get hold compared to the 243. I would appreciate any feedback about the 6mm-284 from anyone, and some possible fav loads etc.

Im becoming more interested about the 6mm. And although there are some impressive ballistics from the 6mm-284 and 6mm-06, 243wssm, however it seem quite difficult to beat the good old pope gun, due to many external factors (good cases, huge amount of good bullets etc). I'm not saying the 243 is the best round of all time or anything :lol: :lol: but i would probs go as far as saying it would be the best round in the 6mm class for varminting - medium game hunting.

cheers lads
User avatar
HiWall
Site Admin
Posts: 854
Joined: Sat Dec 09, 2006 1:51 am
Favourite Cartridge: .25/06
Location: Brisbane

Re: 6mm-284 vs 243

Post by HiWall »

I wouldn't say that it is the best of the 6mm's mate, but that depends on what exactly you are looking for. Ammo and cases are easy to get and relatively inexpensive, while most of the others can't claim that advantage.

Your 6/284 will need case resizing from .284 Win brass (or 6.5/284) which is expensive compared to .243 brass. You could neck down .25/06 to 6mm for your 6/06. .240 Wby Mag brass is readily available, excellent quality (made by Norma) but expensive. All of these will easily outperform the .243 Win by 200/300 fps.

Bullet availability is not as issue, it is the same for all, although the higher performance of the bigger cases may require better/tougher bullets to be used and they will cost a little more as well.

So if you want better performance than the .243 Win, there are plenty of ways to achieve it, but with greater effort and cost.

OR

You could just buy a good .25/06 and have a better all rounder without the fuss - this has the added advantage of never having to admit that you own a .243 Win.
louie the fly
.17 HMR
Posts: 210
Joined: Sun Aug 24, 2008 11:49 pm
Favourite Cartridge: 25-06
Location: WA

Re: 6mm-284 vs 243

Post by louie the fly »

fair points mate.
Do you reckon its worth fiddling around to try and outperform the 243 with other 6mm or just go the 25-06?? the 25-06 is pretty farking good really. does everything a 6mm will do with bigger bullets and more authority.

thanks for your comments. i guess i do agree with you 8)
chris.tyne
.270 Winchester
Posts: 1440
Joined: Thu Jun 07, 2007 9:56 pm
Favourite Cartridge: 6BR
Location: Usually underneath

Re: 6mm-284 vs 243

Post by chris.tyne »

HiWall wrote:you could just buy a good .25/06 and have a better all rounder without the fuss - this has the added advantage of never having to admit that you own a .243 Win.
Hiwall :) I love it.................thats gold.



Regards Chris.
dave
7mm08 Rem
Posts: 985
Joined: Mon Jul 10, 2006 1:30 pm

Re: 6mm-284 vs 243

Post by dave »

If you want a 243wssm this ones on used guns......goes alright too :wink:

viewtopic.php?f=1&t=9142
User avatar
Jugs
New Member
Posts: 50
Joined: Thu Feb 22, 2007 3:05 pm
Location: Sunbury, VIC

Re: 6mm-284 vs 243

Post by Jugs »

You could go a 243AI and I will work out a deal on dies and cases

Jugs
Sam Walker
.222 Remington
Posts: 360
Joined: Sat Aug 05, 2006 9:13 am
Location: The Awesome NT

Re: 6mm-284 vs 243

Post by Sam Walker »

6.5-284 was all the rage among F Classers a few years ago....had a rep for short barrel life (1000-1200 rounds) though. So 6-284 would be even harder on barrels
louie the fly
.17 HMR
Posts: 210
Joined: Sun Aug 24, 2008 11:49 pm
Favourite Cartridge: 25-06
Location: WA

Re: 6mm-284 vs 243

Post by louie the fly »

i dunno bout the wssm :lol:

jugs,
wat rifles do you have in 243AI?

im defs getting excited about the 25-06.
User avatar
Jugs
New Member
Posts: 50
Joined: Thu Feb 22, 2007 3:05 pm
Location: Sunbury, VIC

Re: 6mm-284 vs 243

Post by Jugs »

LTF

It is one of my 500m Fly rifles

It would consistently shoot around 3-4in mark at 500 but I was looking for better. Velocity I could get the 107 SMK running up to 3250fps and easy to shoot.

Jugs
adamjp
.270 Winchester
Posts: 1293
Joined: Fri Mar 20, 2009 4:01 pm
Favourite Cartridge: 30/06
Location: Sthn NSW

Re: 6mm-284 vs 243

Post by adamjp »

HiWall wrote: You could just buy a good .25/06 and have a better all rounder without the fuss - this has the added advantage of never having to admit that you own a .243 Win.
+1

120gn bullet @ 2800fps = hits hard
75gn bullet @ 3500fps = flat as a models chest
buying commonly available cases = easy to feed
not admitting you own a 243 = priceless :bang:
User avatar
frakka
22-250 Remington
Posts: 595
Joined: Thu Oct 09, 2008 11:43 am
Favourite Cartridge: 223 Rem
Location: Central Wheat Belt WA

Re: 6mm-284 vs 243

Post by frakka »

louie the fly wrote: .......for everything up to goat sized game......
If that’s the question any 6mm is more than adequate for the task. Why would you want a bigger case, longer action, more powder, more noise and more recoil…..I don’t understand that thinking.

(I'm just ignoring that other blasphemous remark :wink: )
bushchook
.223 Remington
Posts: 420
Joined: Tue Oct 31, 2006 11:23 pm
Favourite Cartridge: .220 Swift
Location: Wheatbelt W.A.

Re: 6mm-284 vs 243

Post by bushchook »

adamjp wrote:
HiWall wrote: You could just buy a good .25/06 and have a better all rounder without the fuss - this has the added advantage of never having to admit that you own a .243 Win.
+1

120gn bullet @ 2800fps = hits hard
75gn bullet @ 3500fps = flat as a models chest
buying commonly available cases = easy to feed
not admitting you own a 243 = priceless :bang:
Can easily get 3650FPS from the 75gn V Max out of a .243AI with AR2209 . The standard .243 would only be 50 - 60 FPS behind. That said the .25/06 is certainly more gun and is a logical step up if you want more punch than the .243 has to offer . Goats and the .243 go together like fish and chips though.
Rinso
.338 Lapua Magnum
Posts: 2055
Joined: Thu Jul 27, 2006 11:09 pm
Favourite Cartridge: 25.06
Location: Hervey Bay Qld

Re: 6mm-284 vs 243

Post by Rinso »

Well heres the best 2nd hand 25-06 going, comes with everything you could want including load data, your choice of scopes ie Vortex 6.5-20 or Leupold 6.5-20.
It looks good, shoots great and has taken everything from crows to deer (often at rather long ranges) without issue.

http://ausvarmint.kjd84.com/forum/viewt ... 70a278c406

Make an offer
Post Reply